Saxperience - Citroen Saxo Forum

Saxperience - Citroen Saxo Forum (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Chat... (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   vts v starlet glanza v renault 5 gt turbo! (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/showthread.php?t=271432)

carl_hughes 21st November 2009 21:32

vts v starlet glanza v renault 5 gt turbo!
 
which would you buy?

i dont know which to save up for?!

Anthony 21st November 2009 21:34

vts obv, but then again i'm i own one ;).

saxokid100 21st November 2009 21:35

vts everytime............

carl_hughes 21st November 2009 21:35

yeah a cammed vts maybe

look better and cheaper !

Thecherry0121 21st November 2009 21:35

r5s tend to be very unreliable through the winter but if you did get one try and find a raider :)

benJee_VTR 21st November 2009 21:37

R5 GTT always wanted one of those :y:



robert_waite 21st November 2009 21:38

As above r5 raider the blue one with black wheels. They are an old car now though. I would be tempted by the glanza as I love boost. Gotta be the vts though with some sensible mods to keep up with the glanza.

carl_hughes 21st November 2009 21:41

what bhp are the glanza's

rkid147 21st November 2009 21:42

130bhp standard in a glanza

Chewy

0rang3peel 21st November 2009 22:15

glanzas look like shite, r5's are to old / unreliable so vts

AshKeeble 21st November 2009 22:18

R5s are too unreliable. Glanzas are mostly owned by boy racers and usually ragged to pieces. Take your time and save up for a slightly modded VTS. I would if i could.

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 22:20

depends how much you wana spend...

mint R5gtt is near impossible to find, keeping it mint = just as hard

glanzas, can be silly fast in a straight line, but not great in the corners

saxo's = cheap fun

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 22:55

i witht the boyo's here like, glanzas are wank, can get silly power but onky in a straight line as youll never get one round a corner..... ever...should be american tbh, r5s i fucking love and will own a mint one very soon, be a VERY longwinded project but itl be a car i keep till i die, not really a fan of the vts (8V FTW!!!) but id go for the vts out of all, simpley dislike glanzas = wank anyway... r5s aint cheap and are too old and abused (not to mention rare as rocking horse shit) to find decent one plus how unreliable they are to begin with mean vts is the only viable option and is a good all rounder with good scope for improvement, ...................... but that r5 on piston heads ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! think i just did a sex wee

Junaid 21st November 2009 22:57

Renault GT5 Turbo
but if i had alot of Money
Glanza turbo, would eat the saxo n GT5

Junaid 21st November 2009 22:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thecherry0121 (Post 3859661)
r5s tend to be very unreliable through the winter but if you did get one try and find a raider :)

is the Raider like a VTS version of the GT5?

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 22:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by BoiRacer (Post 3859917)
Renault GT5 Turbo
but if i had alot of Money
Glanza turbo, would eat the saxo n GT5

are you sure? ;)

Junaid 21st November 2009 23:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3859923)
are you sure? ;)

lool been told the Glanza turbos are kicking out over 200-300bhp?
well the ones that have been moded

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by BoiRacer (Post 3859917)
Renault GT5 Turbo
but if i had alot of Money
Glanza turbo, would eat the saxo n GT5

silliest thing ive heard in a few days, ive seen some fooking animal 5 turbos aswell as what can be achieved with a vts, "if youve gotta the money... you gotta the power!!!!"

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 23:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by BoiRacer (Post 3859942)
lool been told the Glanza turbos are kicking out over 200-300bhp?
well the ones that have been moded

bhp isnt everything

standard, theyre 130

can be upto over 500

Chr15 21st November 2009 23:08

R5

If I want to go fast I'd buy a Bugatti.

Junaid 21st November 2009 23:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3859954)
bhp isnt everything

standard, theyre 130

can be upto over 500

fuck me 500?
surely vts cant match that even modded

3cott 21st November 2009 23:14

Neither

Ide get a 172 or a 182

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 23:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by BoiRacer (Post 3859973)
fuck me 500?
surely vts cant match that even modded

as i said, dont get seduced by big numbers

can the starlet put 500bhp down?

whats to say you cant build a saxo with that much power?

how reliable is a heavily modded engine?

too much power isnt that good in a small car

standard for standard - VTS pisses on it on track, it's a good handling car with readily avaliable torque

theres a lot more to building a winning car than just a powerful engine..

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3859982)
as i said, dont get seduced by big numbers

can the starlet put 500bhp down?

whats to say you cant build a saxo with that much power?

how reliable is a heavily modded engine?

too much power isnt that good in a small car

standard for standard - VTS pisses on it on track, it's a good handling car with readily avaliable torque

theres a lot more to building a winning car than just a powerful engine..

hear hear, and GLANZAS ARE SHIT!!!!!!!

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 23:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by 3cott (Post 3859980)
Neither

Ide get a 172 or a 182

theres much more cars in a similar price range that id have i think

i love a clio 182 trophy, but realistically, is it the best option for £7000?

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3860005)
theres much more cars in a similar price range that id have i think

i love a clio 182 trophy, but realistically, is it the best option for £7000?

IF I WANTED A NICE SPE'D CAR I WOULDNT PICK ONE THAT CORNERS ON 3 WHEELS TBH, MAKES SENSE TO GO ROUND ON 4 BEING A VEHICLE WITH 4 WHEELS........... just realised im shouting...... fuck it am not re typing ;)

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 23:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackie_2k5 (Post 3860010)
IF I WANTED A NICE SPE'D CAR I WOULDNT PICK ONE THAT CORNERS ON 3 WHEELS TBH, MAKES SENSE TO GO ROUND ON 4 BEING A VEHICLE WITH 4 WHEELS........... just realised im shouting...... fuck it am not re typing ;)

a trophy is one of the best handling FWD cars out there, a lot of stiff chassis cars can get up on 3 wheels,

scottyvtr 21st November 2009 23:30

i would have the vts or a R5GTT, i hate jap crap, as blackie pointed out there have been some awesome R5's infact i would say its one of the fastest cars ive ever been in the first being a saph cossie 4x4 and agrees with the how much you want to spend on power gains???!!!

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:32

BUT... theres better about and quite simpley a car that started life with 4 wheels shouldnt corner with 3 IMO, not saying it doesnt handle well for a fwd car, i like them but there is better and with the moeny we're talking id buy something alot diff tbh, my lass wants a 182 lol, just learning to drive, said id make her a look a like so shes happy

Junaid 21st November 2009 23:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3859982)
as i said, dont get seduced by big numbers

can the starlet put 500bhp down?

whats to say you cant build a saxo with that much power?

how reliable is a heavily modded engine?

too much power isnt that good in a small car

standard for standard - VTS pisses on it on track, it's a good handling car with readily avaliable torque

theres a lot more to building a winning car than just a powerful engine..


good point

Ashleyp 21st November 2009 23:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackie_2k5 (Post 3860028)
BUT... theres better about and quite simpley a car that started life with 4 wheels shouldnt corner with 3 IMO, not saying it doesnt handle well for a fwd car, i like them but there is better and with the moeny we're talking id buy something alot diff tbh, my lass wants a 182 lol, just learning to drive, said id make her a look a like so shes happy

i like the 182's a lot. i just think for £7k i'd pick something different, although the renault would be cheaper to run than most of its "performance" rivals in the same price bracket

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by scottyvtr (Post 3860023)
i would have the vts or a R5GTT, i hate jap crap, as blackie pointed out there have been some awesome R5's infact i would say its one of the fastest cars ive ever been in the first being a saph cossie 4x4 and agrees with the how much you want to spend on power gains???!!!

mate had an insanley RAPID r5, he was a gypsie and somehoe acquired it through some mean, was blisteringly quick, id say it had over 15k under the bonnet, and about5-6 year ago that was alot of money on an engine alone, long story short he was wanted and dumped it after being chased off the police(cleanly left evrthing for dust) but they bumped into the car searchinf later that night and it was the last that was seen of it, :n:

blackie_2k5 21st November 2009 23:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3860039)
i like the 182's a lot. i just think for £7k i'd pick something different, although the renault would be cheaper to run than most of its "performance" rivals in the same price bracket

if i was looking for a decnt all rounder with 7k id go for an 00'ish impreza decent cond low'ish miles say 3-3.5k for the right car and spend the rest on tuning it, even though im not a great fan of them, it works as a good fast car/drivers car/family car/ weekend track slag

scot-ish 22nd November 2009 06:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ashleyp (Post 3859982)
as i said, dont get seduced by big numbers

can the starlet put 500bhp down?

whats to say you cant build a saxo with that much power?

how reliable is a heavily modded engine?

too much power isnt that good in a small car

0standard for standard - VTS pisses on it on track, it's a good handling car with readily avaliable torque

theres a lot more to building a winning car than just a powerful engine..


500bhp starlet??

nope, not on the 4efte or the 5efte

i believe 448 is the highest, but there is one in the north east running 3sgte, and another down south, pushin 500

a standard starlet gt aint as bad handling as people go on

its always people whove never driven the cars, who from hearsay, say there shite. a standard starlet, with a ARB, adjustable panahrd rod, and coilovers, will be as good on track as a vts, not to mention the power of starlet compared to the vts for the same cash

personally, i would go for a starlet GT (as i own one) and i dont like the glanza that much. my car is standard,then i spent £600, and its 190bhp, alot of them come standard with a LSD, will put the power down no probs, no lag, full boost at 3k rpm, and would tank a vts in a str8 line or track, would only really be worth playin with a vts on bodies, and that would have to be a well setup one, or a turbo'd one, but the £££ it cost to set a VTS up turbo'd, not where i would put my money.

you can buy a decent starlet for 2k, and 4k will get you a forged TD04 setup running 300bhp

but then again, on this website, everyone is gunna say, get a VTS, because after all, its a saxo website


it depends on your budget, a ibiza cupra is a good shout aswell.

VTR-Chris-VTR 22nd November 2009 07:29

Glanza all day long.......personal experience......btw there 133bhp iirc ;)

VTS = unreliable had 2 VTS's that fucked up on me big time

And yeh Glanza's will beat VTS's & R5

Ive had both a Glanza and Starlet GT.......and i must say the Starlet Gt by far out handled my Saxo

I had mine pushing 160bhp just by uping the boost to 0.8, meshed turbo, de-cat and full exhaust system and was pushing 0-60's in 6.5secs approx

But yeh there a marmite car.....you either love um or hate them, but at the end of the day there still a good car even tho there 13/14 years old now.

Plus i would choose jap over anything french anyday......i did like the saxo's but i moved on and glad i did.

But this is a Saxo site.....so your all gonna back the VTS up what ever people say.


Predator_R32 22nd November 2009 07:37

5 Turbo everytime always loved them

Ashleyp 22nd November 2009 09:19

ive driven a starlet GT, and theres not much difference to a VTS.

my mates GT is currently running over 200bhp, in a straight line it'd blow away a vts. but as i said, it's not all about power

tuning potential is there from the starlet engines, but also parts / repairs can be more costly and often need importing

imo starlets are typical of the older style jap cars - all go and no show, awful styling.

glanza's are also becomming one of the new chav charriots due to being cheap boost

i personally wouldnt buy one unless from an importer, but i dont know enough about the car's to really call that an informed choice

Heliosphan 22nd November 2009 09:46

Hardly any Glanzas around where I live and for that reason I'd have one. How can anyone say they're chav motors? I've seen more badly modified chavved up Saxos than any other car apart from Corsas. Also, people that say Glanzas don't corner well. Pah. Doesn't matter if you're not on track does it? Nothing against Saxos, but I've had a Vts and life's too short to buy the same car twice! ;)

I'd have a R5 as first choice but finding a decent one will be hard. If you do, I'm sure you'll end up paying top dollar and is it worth paying top dollar for an old Renault.....maybe it is.

Quick point on Clios. I'd never pay £7000 for one. As far as I'm concerned, Cliosports are nothing but a "cheap" performance option. Money approaching 10k buys a far better car. Also, I don't buy a car just becasue a magazine rates it as one of the best.

Ashleyp 22nd November 2009 09:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heliosphan (Post 3860466)
Hardly any Glanzas around where I live and for that reason I'd have one. How can anyone say they're chav motors? I've seen more badly modified chavved up Saxos than any other car apart from Corsas. Also, people that say Glanzas don't corner well. Pah. Doesn't matter if you're not on track does it? Nothing against Saxos, but I've had a Vts and life's too short to buy the same car twice! ;)

I'd have a R5 as first choice but finding a decent one will be hard. If you do, I'm sure you'll end up paying top dollar and is it worth paying top dollar for an old Renault.....maybe it is.

Quick point on Clios. I'd never pay £7000 for one. As far as I'm concerned, Cliosports are nothing but a "cheap" performance option. Money approaching 10k buys a far better car. Also, I don't buy a car just becasue a magazine rates it as one of the best.

i agree on the cliosport point, awesome little cars, but £7k opens up a pretty big field of car options. granted the running costs may be more, but a cliosport doesnt seem a 7k car to me.

glanza's are becomming popular with the chavs, that doesnt mean saxos arent chav car's..

if i wanted straight line fun, i wouldnt buy a FWD hatchback...

Jazz 22nd November 2009 10:03

If tuning is your thing, I'd have to choose a Glanza/Starlet. R5's are delicate these days and once fettled with they generally have no end of problems. Having said that if you could find a decent standard R5 GTT then I'd snap it up and take good care of it.

A standard VTS is probably a better drivers car than a standard Glanza, but there's no denying that a Turbo motor will be better if tuned correctly. Once a VTS is cammed/mapped at around 140-150bhp, extracting more power becomes a question of how many thousands you're ready to throw at it. Less cash thrown at the little Toyota will see you sailing well past that mark.

It depends on what you want in a small hot-hatch tbh.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:54.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.