Saxperience - Citroen Saxo Forum

Saxperience - Citroen Saxo Forum (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/index.php)
-   Saxo Engine/Performance (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   which headgasket?! (http://www.saxperience.com/forum/showthread.php?t=474842)

smokeandpoke 12th June 2017 14:51

which headgasket?!
 
Afternoon


Had my JP4 head skimmed for use on a J4 block.
For now, I'm planning on running it n/a just to let any problems worm their way out.

Am I correct in thinking I need to use the JP4 haedgasket for clearance?
Also, when I had it skimmed the bloke didn't give me a measurement he just described it as a 'light skim'


Therefore I have various queries...

A) Will I get away with one headgasket
B) Will it run okay if I double them up now in anticipation for turbo time, or will this cause more harm than good and is generally frowned upon? I'm sure people have got away with half a bar on double gaskets?


Thanks guys

Chipwizards 12th June 2017 22:19

Doubling gaskets isn't really ideal.
How much power and torque are you looking for?

axsaxoman 13th June 2017 08:34

dry build engine to see
refit head with old gasket --just nip it down +time up cams
having already put a lump of clay ontop of a piston --turn engine over 2 turns by hand with no plugs in it -remove head and see how much clearnace you have --by thickness of clay

smokeandpoke 14th June 2017 15:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chipwizards (Post 6549372)
Doubling gaskets isn't really ideal.
How much power and torque are you looking for?

I'd be happy with 200bhp on a safe 7psi. Might be a tad optimistic.
Want it to be reliable enough that it starts and runs every time, a few times a week. Just want it to be good fun, I'm not trying to push it or blow it up.

I've spoken to a few people and apparently running double gaskets on a n/a set up (just to get it on the road and find any other little niggles) will wreak havoc on the engine. I understand it will lower compression a tad but wasn't too sure how much it would effect it in the meantime until its all built.

I know the proper way to do it is decomp plate, I was just trying to save wasting a headgasket and having to buy a second set of headbolts!

smokeandpoke 14th June 2017 15:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by axsaxoman (Post 6549380)
dry build engine to see
refit head with old gasket --just nip it down +time up cams
having already put a lump of clay ontop of a piston --turn engine over 2 turns by hand with no plugs in it -remove head and see how much clearnace you have --by thickness of clay

I have since spoken to the engineer and he said it was literally just a clean up.
He said running a standard gasket will give it a bit of a tweak - as the C/R will be a touch lower, but he doesn't specialise in citroens so I don't think he understands the different clearances between the engines.

Clay idea seems a very safe and sensible way to check, I shall bear that in mind! Either way, it will need a new gasket as I understand I should use the corresponding gasket for that particular head - in my case I should use a jp4 head.

I think I will have to check the clearance with standard gasket as you have stated - I just wondered what people used as the norm when completing this conversion. I should have thought a +0.2 gasket should suffice (without checking it)



While I've got you - are you in agreement that running double gaskets to decomp the engine (as you would for a budget turbo build) whilst running N/A will upset the engine?

axsaxoman 15th June 2017 08:16

7psi max and correct ecu mods --no need to lower comp ratio
modern OEM turbo cars run 10/1 comp ratio and 1bar of boost
old wrc cars ran 3 bar of boost +10/1 comp --so its all in the ecu +turbo control

smokeandpoke 19th June 2017 14:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by axsaxoman (Post 6549425)
7psi max and correct ecu mods --no need to lower comp ratio
modern OEM turbo cars run 10/1 comp ratio and 1bar of boost
old wrc cars ran 3 bar of boost +10/1 comp --so its all in the ecu +turbo control

Will be getting hold of a standalone ECU as I believe the 5th injector method to be a bit grimy and totally 90's!!

I was not aware the standard engine would take boost at standard compression, I would be lowering merely as a precaution?

MartinObviously 19th June 2017 19:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by smokeandpoke (Post 6549463)
Will be getting hold of a standalone ECU as I believe the 5th injector method to be a bit grimy and totally 90's!!

I was not aware the standard engine would take boost at standard compression, I would be lowering merely as a precaution?

The standard ECU can be mapped to work with boost. just need a map which reads postive pressure.

I've seen it! :homme: someone did it with their red C2 :panic:


compression isn't a huge factor, fuel type, quantity, air temp and ignition timing I think affect how much boost you can use more - things which affect knock. I'll get corrected no doubt, I'm pretty clueless. I'm a diesel man at heart and i upped my compression to 25:1... with boost :fcuk:

smokeandpoke 20th June 2017 15:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by MartinObviously (Post 6549470)
The standard ECU can be mapped to work with boost. just need a map which reads postive pressure.

I've seen it! :homme: someone did it with their red C2 :panic:


compression isn't a huge factor, fuel type, quantity, air temp and ignition timing I think affect how much boost you can use more - things which affect knock. I'll get corrected no doubt, I'm pretty clueless. I'm a diesel man at heart and i upped my compression to 25:1... with boost :fcuk:


Really? I'm sure someone could do it, but for the time and effort (and effectiveness) I would probably still go standalone unless it is considerably cheaper than a standalone.

25:1 on a saxo? wow!
That's nothing for a diesel, but I am surprised your saxo didn't turn itself inside out hahaha!!

gti180craig 20th June 2017 16:17

Mine is running standard ecu with a 2 bar map sensor Wayne from chipwizards Is the man to see

MartinObviously 20th June 2017 21:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by gti180craig (Post 6549478)
Mine is running standard ecu with a 2 bar map sensor Wayne from chipwizards Is the man to see

Yes!

Quote:

Originally Posted by smokeandpoke (Post 6549477)
Really? I'm sure someone could do it, but for the time and effort (and effectiveness) I would probably still go standalone unless it is considerably cheaper than a standalone.

25:1 on a saxo? wow!
That's nothing for a diesel, but I am surprised your saxo didn't turn itself inside out hahaha!!

Of course having your standard ECU mapped to accept boost is WAY cheaper. it'll cost you a sensor, some injectors and a day on dyno.

Yes 23:1 standard 1.5D, it's indirect injection :cool:

smokeandpoke 20th June 2017 21:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by MartinObviously (Post 6549479)
Yes!



Of course having your standard ECU mapped to accept boost is WAY cheaper. it'll cost you a sensor, some injectors and a day on dyno.

Yes 23:1 standard 1.5D, it's indirect injection :cool:

Oh sorry I assumed petrol!

I didn't think there were many people that could do it, if you know of anyone in the south east get them to get in touch!!

Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk

smokeandpoke 20th June 2017 21:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by gti180craig (Post 6549478)
Mine is running standard ecu with a 2 bar map sensor Wayne from chipwizards Is the man to see

Sorry Craig didn't see this mate.
Where abouts is wayne based?

Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk

gti180craig 21st June 2017 05:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by smokeandpoke (Post 6549481)
Sorry Craig didn't see this mate.
Where abouts is wayne based?

Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk

Near Wigan mate bit Of a drive for u but worth it

AdamH 21st June 2017 10:24

207 map sensor by any chance craig?

gti180craig 21st June 2017 12:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamH (Post 6549484)
207 map sensor by any chance craig?

:y: correct mate also found on a Mini Cooper s and ds3

smokeandpoke 21st June 2017 12:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by gti180craig (Post 6549488)
:y: correct mate also found on a Mini Cooper s and ds3

Nice one mate, solid starting point. I assume it's off the thp one?

Adam my fountain of knowledge as usual!!!!

Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk

AdamH 22nd June 2017 12:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by smokeandpoke (Post 6549489)

Adam my fountain of knowledge as usual!!!!


"blushes"

Yea 1.6 THP, doesn't matter which BHP version :)


PSA 207GTI 1.6 THP
Citroen/Peugeot = Part Number = 1992 R6
BMW/Mini = Part Number = 62 7 535 069 / 13627535069

smokeandpoke 22nd June 2017 12:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamH (Post 6549501)
"blushes"

Yea 1.6 THP, doesn't matter which BHP version :)

Haha you tart!!!
Awesome. I may look into that if I can find someone down this end of the country, gave him a Google and it's a good 4 and a bit hours each way.


Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:58.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.