Saxo Engine/Performance If you're interested in tuning Saxo engines, or if you need to know something which is engine related... this is the place for you. |
 |
|
23rd December 2012, 11:15
|
#21
|
Infrequent Poster
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Bulgaria
Posts: 130
Car(s): Forged Citroen Saxo VTS 16v mk2 (2002)
|
The DP Engineering inlet manifold is very well made really. But It price will be ... but it worths at all! I'm looking too after an aftermarket inlet manifold too so I think to contact DP soon and will post some info after that.
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 12:16
|
#22
|
Frequent Poster
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 591
|
Dp manifolds are cheap compared to some gear...
Don't know why more people don't run nortech manifold, cheaper, based in the uk and will make anything you want!
Oh an you won't have hassles like with the dp stuff.
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 14:05
|
#23
|
Frequent Poster
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: aberdeen
Posts: 634
Car(s): saxo vtr/205 rallye turbo
|
Do they currently make one?
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 15:06
|
#24
|
Saxperience Forum Bum
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Midlands
Posts: 2,530
Car(s): AX 16v Turbo
|
Ross, was the dp mani an improvement? What were you using before?
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 15:17
|
#25
|
Infrequent Poster
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Bulgaria
Posts: 130
Car(s): Forged Citroen Saxo VTS 16v mk2 (2002)
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by gazza808
Dp manifolds are cheap compared to some gear...
Don't know why more people don't run nortech manifold, cheaper, based in the uk and will make anything you want!
Oh an you won't have hassles like with the dp stuff.
|
Hey dude! Can you post us some links of nortech intake manifolds for saxo, images or prices compared with the DP. I've searched google but no results for nortech inlet manifolds for saxo. For DP the best price I've found was 1.015 GBP.
Cheers!
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 16:38
|
#26
|
Frequent Poster
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 591
|
You'll have to enquire with them,
I'm not sure if they have done one,
But they will make anything.
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 16:38
|
#27
|
Super Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Cambridge(ish), UK.
Posts: 10,581
Car(s): BMW 5x M50d.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by e8_pqck
Ross, was the dp mani an improvement? What were you using before?
|
The inlet? yes - was a big improvement - I was using the standard plastic inlet previously, but after titch split one at about 26 psi, I changed immediately to the DP one. The inlet welds are a bit cold on mine and it doesn't have perfect penetration throughout, but it's still fine - but lets remember you're talking about a £1k manifold so I'd expect it to be good!
The DP exhaust manifold was warped. I told DP. they knew about it, and said there was nothing they can do as it's part of how it's made. Mine was warped bad enough to pull a manifold stud out of the head and blow the manifold gasket. Titch's was warped, but not as bad. Brents (now ollies) was the same. And the three I've seen since. They really should get that fixed...
BUT - all the negatives aside, it does the job I want, and is an "off the shelf" item. Danny made his own, as have others, and have done what looks to be a job just as well. It's doable.
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 19:59
|
#28
|
Saxperience Forum Bum
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: South Wales
Posts: 3,076
Car(s): ZX 16v, 205 GTI, 309 Goodwood, 405 MI16.
|
you'd think they'd put it through a mill or surface grinder once its all welded up to make the surface flat, that's what Colin Satchell does.
actually, that'd be awesome, Short satchell inlet with sealed airbox and 8 injectors, as long as Bike bodies will take boost.
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 20:05
|
#29
|
Super Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Cambridge(ish), UK.
Posts: 10,581
Car(s): BMW 5x M50d.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by welshpug
you'd think they'd put it through a mill or surface grinder once its all welded up to make the surface flat, that's what Colin Satchell does.
actually, that'd be awesome, Short satchell inlet with sealed airbox and 8 injectors, as long as Bike bodies will take boost.
|
I had a machine shop mill mine to flatten it out. the bottom bar in this photo is flat. The manifold as you can see is warped in the middle:
A friend has a boosted gsxr1000 - they take boost. I like where you're going with this
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 20:47
|
#30
|
Saxperience Post Whore
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Morley, Leeds
Posts: 8,469
Car(s): Civic ep3 type r powered by TDI NORTH
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ross
I had a machine shop mill mine to flatten it out. the bottom bar in this photo is flat. The manifold as you can see is warped in the middle:
A friend has a boosted gsxr1000 - they take boost. I like where you're going with this 
|
that is shocking mate.
Was talking to mark1311 on here about these in the summer and the quality of them and the warp factor. IIRC he was making a jig to start making his own version out of better materials and better welds (some we have seen were literally surface welds) not sure if he actually made any but the bloke has the skills and equipment to make them.
__________________
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 22:11
|
#31
|
Established Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Farnham Surrey
Posts: 1,542
Car(s): AX GT 16v turbo 6 speed with NOS
205 gti6
E 320
|
£1000 for a decent inlet is alot of money
Rover inlets can be had for £50 ish on ebay and just mod it
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 22:33
|
#32
|
Saxperience Post Whore
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: United Kingdom
Posts: 8,390
|
Tubo?
SUBO!
|
|
|
The Following User Says Thank You to Gabbastard For This Useful Post:
|
|
23rd December 2012, 23:20
|
#33
|
Frequent Poster
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: aberdeen
Posts: 634
Car(s): saxo vtr/205 rallye turbo
|
I had a 20v turbo one for my car but sold it might get another one
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 23:22
|
#34
|
Super Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Cambridge(ish), UK.
Posts: 10,581
Car(s): BMW 5x M50d.
|
Aye I watched Titch make a rover inlet fit. It's a good solution (although id personally probably go the c2 vts route if staying with a standard inlet as its a direct bolt on, albeit much more expensive lol).
|
|
|
23rd December 2012, 23:48
|
#35
|
Established Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Farnham Surrey
Posts: 1,542
Car(s): AX GT 16v turbo 6 speed with NOS
205 gti6
E 320
|
Yes but im a tight bastard ross and didnt pay for this inlet
|
|
|
The Following User Says Thank You to tweeqd For This Useful Post:
|
|
23rd December 2012, 23:50
|
#36
|
Super Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Cambridge(ish), UK.
Posts: 10,581
Car(s): BMW 5x M50d.
|
Martin the work you do on the budget you spend staggers me. I wish I had the know how
|
|
|
24th December 2012, 11:05
|
#37
|
Saxperience Forum Bum
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Scotland
Posts: 3,380
|
I had a machine shop mill mine to flatten it out. the bottom bar in this photo is flat. The manifold as you can see is warped in the middle
to be fair to DP or anyone making such a weird shaped +compact ex manifold ,they are always going to have issues with distortion
all those pipes of different lengths ,cold drawn bends +then welded --and not left in a jig and heated up to red heat to stress relieve them --its going to bend and nothing will stop it except for a much thicker flange on the head and then it will just move the bottom flange instead
I have to hand it them though they have managed to convince everyone that they need such a complicated manifold in the first place.
Its nonsense and just bling anyway .
same goes for the inlet manifold right over the top
a bmw 740 --4.5litre v8 runs a 60mm t/body up to 7000rpm and makes near 400 n/a ,runs like a sweety at all times --so why when you are cramming in twice the volume of air would you need a 70mm t/body on a 1587cc engine --you don,t
same goes for the primary pipe sizes on the ex manifold ,and to make it worse they all come together and the crossectional area at that point is very restricted
this cuases lots of heat to back up ,add to that the poor airflow around the manifold and you are going to get uneven expansion .
for those of you who want to prove /disprove what I am saying
take tapping from the ex manofld just before turbo --a bit of brake pipe extended out then rubber to a gauge --measure the back pressure required to get your boost required ,then watch it climbs as you go further up the rpm range -- all that wasted power and extra heat you don,t want to make .
I did this years ago with a saab 900 and by bleeding off the extra pressure I increased engine output with std turbo to get a 25% increase on what the turbo was rated at --
the turbo stopped glowing as did the ex manifold ,
this is why the VNT turbo came into being
which brings us nicely on to the choices of turbo,s --DP specifyied the gt28 ,as it was something old fashioned they could get cheaply and its why the lag is so bad and won,t spool up till more than half way up your rpm range
its really is not matched to the engine at all ,just happens to fit same flange as the r5/nissan silva turbo they started the project with .
its big its crude
yes it can make enough power --but its not a good choice due to its physical size .
a smaller turbo with a simpler more compact manifold will do all it needs to do and keep the heat problems to a minimum .
I am suprised some of the turboguru,s have not realised these simple things
If you must have a manifold of that shape then there should be slip joint on all the primaries to allow for this so it can expand and contract without moving everything about .
that will give leaks when its cold ,but on a race car of ultimate spec thats not a problem .
look at your favorite std turbo cars ,which with chipping etc can make more bhp than your saxo , + alot easier and you will find very simple cast manifolds and even some of those have a slip joint to stop cracking of manifold .
the bolt holes will be at least 2-3 mm larger than stud size for same reason to allow for expansion
the large primary sizes on the tubular manifolds will make more lag as the gas speed will be lower ,untill it hits the restrictive turbo flange,which will cause turbulance and not do what a std cast manifold does
most are split into 1+4 and 2+3 to give nice puses to the turbine
best example I can think of at present is the toyota mr2 turbo --which uses the twin entry ct28--boosts from 1500rpm --strongly and can give 2.0 bar below 3k--you can,t use that much boost anyway --,its just to show what a well matched manifold+turbo can achieve
If you study the manifolds of the cars your turbo came from you will probably find they are larger where they join your welded up flange but are much smaller in primary size--to keep gas speed up.
now common sense says if the turbo maker decided on that flange size ,then you do not need any larger sizes in your manifold ,anywhere
and if there were any great performance gains to be had with a fabricated manifold they would have used one --costs would be minimal for them when they are making thousands of them
If there are any small power losses due to the manifold --they just up the boost a bit .
now it is said that turbo,s sap less power than super chargers and I would agree to an extent --
with s/c we make the power then use some to drive the s/c unit ,but if the turbo installation is correct there should be less power loss than the s/c
studying lots of graphs and print outs for years from both s/c and turbo installs ,at boost levels the s/c can attain ,as its limted to around 1.2 bar for most installs ,
then the results do not back it up
the conclusion is simple
the expected gains from using a turbo do not manifest themselves because there are other losses --
the turbo has the advantage of being able to run higher boosts,so can hide the power losses very easily ,which show up by excess heat and fuel consumption .
It is well known I do not like turbo,s in small front wheel drive cars ,due to the non civilised way the power is deleivered with all that means to drivability and damage to transmission etc.
It is also why the std modern 200bhp+ turbo cars need all the tricky gadgets ,motorised throttle electronic boost ,ESP ,traction control etc to be acceptable
I am not against turbo,s at all and I am writing this ,as much to help with any new proects .not to slag off turbo power in general
__________________
when the flag drops the bulshit stops.
owner of GMC motorsport 01671404030/01671403699
Last edited by axsaxoman; 24th December 2012 at 12:05.
|
|
|
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to axsaxoman For This Useful Post:
|
|
24th December 2012, 11:21
|
#38
|
Super Moderator
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Cambridge(ish), UK.
Posts: 10,581
Car(s): BMW 5x M50d.
|
Thanks for taking the time to write that John - appreciated
I don't argue with any of what you've written - the 70mm tb is something I would change if starting again for sure (back to 60 or 65mm max). On a small displacement engine with a large tb, making part throttle behave nicely is a real pain (by part throttle I mean the first 1-2% opening). Crawling along in traffic on/off throttle territory.
You've hit the nail on the hear re the warped manifolds - they do use a jig but I think what they should do (IMO of course, I'm not a metal worker) is use a much thicker flange (half as thick again perhaps) and mill it down once finished. So factor in the (less) warping due to the thicker flange, then mill it snooker table smooth. But of course, that costs money and a little extra time.
|
|
|
24th December 2012, 11:23
|
#39
|
Saxperience Post Whore
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: dudley United Kingdom (England)
Posts: 6,790
Car(s): 106 gti/ SEAT LCR
|
Wow, probably the first time in a while I agree with most of what you say there John
I'll have driven every form of aspiration/boost in my car soon so I'll give a small write up to how I have personally found each option to be.
__________________
Boost pressure is underrated
|
|
|
24th December 2012, 11:49
|
#40
|
Saxperience Forum Bum
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Scotland
Posts: 3,380
|
[B][You've hit the nail on the hear re the warped manifolds - they do use a jig /B]
Yes for sure they use a jig to make it ,but ,they do not then stress relieve it AFTER welding by heating ,still in a jig ,all up evenly in a big oven +then cool it slowly
__________________
when the flag drops the bulshit stops.
owner of GMC motorsport 01671404030/01671403699
|
|
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 18:47.
|